Twisted Thoughts And Thoughtful Truths On Thursday #033
Twisted Thoughts And Thoughtful Truths On Thursday #033 – “Stroked Out!”
I am a victim!
I figure making that statement should help me identify with at least half of society right now, so what a great place to start. In any event, in this one, very specific case, it’s actually true. Maybe.
Don’t go getting this story twisted now…95% of the tales of modern-day victimhood come from some kind of a place of privilege, and I’d be the first to tell you that this one does too. As I’ve expressed many times throughout the years, I’ve been a proud pirate for as long as I can remember, plundering the internet for mainstream music for longer than Metallica has been bitching about people doing it. You indies are all safe from my thievery…I’m not saying any of this justifies my behavior, but hell yes, there’s a whole bunch of you out there that are plenty familiar with the fact that I’ve been out there on a ton of the Bandcamp Fridays buying your music, directly from you, without all those marketing, promotion, and management teams trying to horn in on the money you deserve for all the amazing things that you do. As far as the mainstream goes, again – not to justify my habits of downloading, but I have quite likely been to more concerts in a month than most people go to in a lifetime, I buy your merch, and when you go to bat for some kind of social cause, I’ve probably contributed something to that as well. Trust me when I tell you, my closet is stuffed to the gills and every time I bring home yet another band T-shirt from the concert I just went to, my wife rolls her eyes, and we laugh while trying to find a hanger for it. Fret not mainstreamers, I promise you, you’re still making plenty of bucks from me. Do I stream your shit on Spotify and help you earn another 0.000001th of a cent on your shiny new single? No. No I did not. If there was a way around that, I’m sure I found it. For what it’s worth, I probably watched your YouTube ad though. I am also a relentless mouthpiece for everything & anything that I like to listen to, recommending it to others, getting other people to shows, posting live stuff online to help you bolster your already burgeoning fanbases…I might be a pirate, yes – but there’s value in having me on your side.
All that being said, I do NOT expect to be bamboozled. And I have been.
I’ll detail some more wrongs I’ve been on both sides before I get to the main meat of this story, because that’s the objective and fair way to frame this. Way back when at the dawn of the internet age, when my kind were first beginning to realize that we didn’t have to pay $39.99 for a three-song import CD any longer, we used to use this wonderful technology that is called FTP. Familiar with it? If you know, you know…and if you don’t, well…enjoy Spotify Premium I guess. Anyhow. The basic gist is that it was an old-school system that allowed you to set your own parameters in terms of what you chose to share with the world, be it pictures or music or anything otherwise online. For the most part, people built their collections on a give something to get something type of system, as in, I might have to upload YOU a song, but in return, I’d have the opportunity to peruse your collection and take ten, or twenty, or an unlimited amount, depending on whatever rules you chose to set up for your FTP system. And so, YES – there’s a much younger version of myself that decided to take on the task of uploading a then-unknown band called Nickelback to just about everyone I downloaded from back then. You’re welcome world – I’m one of the people responsible for their eventual global domination, having introduced countless folks across the map to a tiny band breaking out in Vancouver that nobody even knew of yet. Whoops. It didn’t always work…I spent just as much time doing that as I did with the Matthew Good Band, and that didn’t nearly have the same effect, just sayin.’ There’s no accounting for taste, as they say. All-in-all though, FTP transfers were where things started, then online programs like Audio Galaxy and Bear Share and Napster and the floodgates all opened up. Why something like FTP would often be different than the rest is simple – if you were certain you had a reliable source, you didn’t really ever have to check on the quality of an actual file. Like, you’d have a kind of consistency you could bank on…similar volumes, similar file labels, and under the right circumstances, you knew it was what you were actually intending to listen to. Call us pirates, call us whatever you want – we had a code! We had integrity.
Those days are no longer…but perhaps they never were.
One of the most exciting moments of my nerdy life occurred back in 2002, when the movie 8 Mile came out. Like everyone else at the time, I wanted that soundtrack. Taking my usual place in my computer chair, I got to downloading like I had become accustomed to, and got myself a copy of it as quick as I could. Much to my surprise when I pushed play, I hadn’t downloaded it at all. Instead, I got some indie rapper’s music – a duo actually, who are still unknown to me to this very day, yet I probably listened to them just last week. The rap was among the most terrible I’ve ever heard and still is, but this duo became iconic inside our circle of friends, and we would turn these horrible songs up as far as our stereos would go, laughing our heads off at some of the insane lines these guys were spitting on bars. But it’s not like I had seen their names attached to the files, you know what I mean? If I had, I would have just moved on and I would have never heard those songs. No – they changed all the internet tags and details to make it look like I was downloading the 8 Mile soundtrack, and it was impossible to know any different before you actually had a listen. When I realized that could actually happen, it was a total game changer. It was terrifying in the sense that I felt like I was going to have to physically verify every single song I’d ever download from there, but I’d be lying to you if I didn’t also say that I recognized the opportunity in front of me as well. You mean to tell me, that I could take my own music, and just label it as something else? Something popular that everyone would actually be interested? It’s a digital form of piggybacking…and I was more than ready to ride. Sorry to say Lana Del Rey, but by the time you came along and released your debut record, I was so well versed in how to go about switching name tags on files, that half her original albums circulating online very well might have been the music of Balls Deep In Your Stepmom instead. Those were fun times. Back then, I was the bamboozler…and you just end up living in this untouchable headspace, thinking it’ll never happen to you, until one day it finally does.
Flash forward too many years and here we are – my uppance has come.
The very minute the new album by The Stokes came out this year, I was already on top of the download button just waiting to click as soon as it showed up. I’ve had an interesting history with that band. Originally, I hated them…I thought they were one-note, one-dimensional, and honestly kind of boring when they first came out. Eventually around the time they released the album Angeles, I began to come around, and by the time they released Comedown Machine afterwards, I was mercilessly hooked. Don’t even get me started on how much I love The New Abnormal or we’ll be here all week – I’m sure you get the idea…I’m a huge fan now, to the point where I’ve recognized the error of my ways and realized that even the earliest stuff is really damn good too. Anyhow. Reality Awaits comes online, and I scoop that sucker up online in my annual giant download harvest as quick as I can get a copy. But we’re no longer living in that beautiful, blissful, carefree time of FTP where I had sources I could trust – like my very first editor when I stepped into music journalism for example, who had gotten all of his Aphex Twin files directly from the man himself. Have a look at some of those file names when you get a moment and you’ll know why that was so crucially important. In fact, Aphex Twin went on to release an album called 26 Mixes For Cash that he claimed he never even made – he just grabbed a bunch of fake Aphex Twin files from the internet, slapped his name on them, and let the money roll right in. That wasn’t the case of course, but it was righteously scathing commentary that should have at least made you chuckle a bit. The point is, we’ve long been in the wild west of the internet, where who knows what is actually what.
So for weeks, months even, I’m LOVING this new album by The Strokes. It is AWESOME. Anyone within earshot of me heard me say it…I couldn’t stop listening. I even buy tickets to see them halfway across the country in Canada, and when upon returning home, I fucking saw them here as well – twice in 2026. And yes, obviously they were incredible…but that’s beside the point for now. When you’re as download savvy as I am, you can recognize a pre-release copy when you hear one…sometimes it’s a fluctuation in the volume or quality of the tracks. As humans of the modern-day digital age, we put up with so much. Back when music came on CDs, a single skip in a song would basically make a whole album useless to me and I’d have to replace it. Before that, cassette tapes would start to wear thin, and those got junked. In the digital age, no one seems to give too much of a shit anymore. You’ve got situations where audio and video don’t even link up, but we still watch or listen…digital skips…files that cut off too soon – there is so much bullshit out there, but we still take what we can get, am I right? So when the songs surrounding the main single called “Going Shopping” sounded like they had thirty percent less volume, I didn’t think too much of it other than noting it in the back of my mind that I’d need to replace the record eventually, and in the situations of mixes for the car on my USB drive, I was quick to correct the volume for the next song that would come on. Other than that, I thought nothing of it – the songs were too damn good for me to give too much of a shit…I was just happy to have them. I was genuinely impressed and intrigued by how they also seemed to incorporate the sonic theme of “Going Shopping” into a few of the other songs as well. Nothing too dominating so that it would feel like a repeat – it was way more subtle than that – but I hadn’t really heard that done too many times in music, save for the occasional reprise, but even that’s a totally different thing. This sounded more like a continuation of a good story, told through music. So hell yeah, I was not only interested in that, but I was addicted to it. I’d bet that I ended up listening to that album more than any other record I’ve listened to this year if I had to wager a guess.
The problem is, I was never listening to Reality Awaits at all.
My first clues should have been the quality of the album, which I should have rightly immediately sought to rectify with a fresh download, but didn’t. The second clue should have been hearing that recurring theme that seemed too similar from track to track, but that didn’t register either. Heck, even when I left the concert The Strokes played in Vancouver, amazed at how little of their new stuff they played in comparison to their back catalog and how they didn’t even play my favorite song from the album, which would have been a guaranteed crowd favorite, I still didn’t clue in. If all that wasn’t reaching me, and it didn’t – I should have known something was up when long-time fan of The Strokes and good friend of mine, Steve Barmash of the band Blackout Lights, said he didn’t even like the new album. That dude has arguably better taste in music than I even have myself, and I was absolutely taken aback by his comments. He’s a straight shooter and never pulls any punches, but I couldn’t believe how off base he was compared to my own, lived experience. It was like he was listening with entirely different ears. So I pushed back, staked my claim, and made sure to express to him that I thought it was their best record.
This isn’t me saying that’s necessarily wrong, but it would have been helpful to know we were listening to two entirely different albums. Oops! Sorry Steve. You were probably right after all. Maybe I’m still a much bigger fan of The New Abnormal. Have I mentioned how much I love that album yet? I have? Ok.
My beautiful wife, was even more addicted to “the new Strokes album” than I was…so again, in the back of my mind, I knew that I had to re-download the record to get us a better copy, because man oh man did she love playing those songs and I was beginning to worry she’s wear out the volume knob cranking up the substandard quality files I had purloined. It took months, maybe even three or four perhaps, before I got back on my download machine and started to click again, at which point I got a fresh copy and made her a new mix for the car for her travels to and from work. I don’t actually get to listen to a whole lot of mainstream stuff anymore at all y’all…I’m so busy here with the independent scene and listening to what YOU create, that my only exposure to mainstream music pretty much happens in the car now when I get to go to a concert or take my dog to the vet across town. But that first crucial switch in between the last mix and the new one always occurs when I’m in the car to do it, because dammit, I want to hear the latest stuff out there too, and that’s the only way I really get exposure to any of it now.
So I switch up the flash drives in the car, The Strokes begins to play, and my wife and I look at each other after having listened to the album for a third of a year straight…and we’re like, what the fuck is this? The volume had been thankfully corrected to its professional standard, but…well…whatever track one was, was an entirely different track one than we’d been listening to for the past four months. When we eventually got to track two, it was the same thing – we’d never even heard that song before. And I know what you’re thinking…surely that’s when I clued in, finally, right? Nope. Still wasn’t quite there – but I did have some sneaking suspicions that I needed to sort out. On the brightest of sides, we had more all-new music from The Strokes to listen to, so we were kinda like FUCK YEAH…but at the same time, I could feel this strange knot of dread tying itself in the pit of my stomach, and there were questions I needed answers to. The first place to start was to check the set-list out from the Vancouver show. I looked at it, and not only DID they actually play my favorite song from the record, but I was 100% convinced they didn’t. You regular readers here KNOW that would be impossible to sneak by me, even in my most inebriated of states…if one of your favorite artists or bands play YOUR song at a show, you remember that shit. So looking over this list and seeing the song called “Dine N’ Dash” on it, I was flabbergasted. How could they have played that and I didn’t hear it? I started to rationalize the situation – I mean, I was in the middle of the pit in front of the stage with hundreds of their most rabid fans just fighting for AIR…so maybe I was too caught up in trying to catch my next breath that I somehow missed them play my favorite song? That still seemed impossible. Then I thought about all the other things…the quality of the original tracks…the recurring theme…the things Steve said – it was all very Usual Suspects-esque, like I was piecing together the mystery of Keyser Soze in real time, and I had just dropped my metaphorical mug to the floor in a crash as I finally realized what had happened.
After chatting with a good friend about this whole experience, who also wanted to know what the end of this story would be, I reluctantly typed “did The Strokes leak an AI album online?” into Google, afraid of the answer I’d find coming back to me. On the brightest side of this scenario, the answer is NO – the band did not release an AI album. On the worst side of this scenario, the answer is YES – someone else out there, did. So for the past four months straight, your favorite music reviewer with the oh-so-discerning ears (and impeccable taste in music I might add), had been listening to a completely fake album. I told you I was a victim! I was hoodwinked! I was bamboozled!
And honestly, I was a bit ashamed of myself for not having realized all this much, much sooner.
Who does that? he shouts into the void, ignoring how hypocritical that is after how many fake Lana Del Rey songs I personally pumped out into the world. Let me be clear – it was always okay for ME to bamboozle YOU – but I never expected to be the other way around. Humble pie anyone? Okay, I’ll have a slice, thanks. Maybe two.
I’ll be real with you and say this has affected me more than you might think. I know most folks wouldn’t probably think twice about it…they’d simply correct their collection and carry on. The thing is – I’m not sure that I even enjoy the ACTUAL Reality Awaits album as much as I was enjoying the FAKE one…at least not yet…time will tell once the shock officially wears off I think. But even as of typing this now, I’d go down with the ship swearing that I was listening to a GREAT RECORD…and it was all, 100%, totally AI.
And I just don’t know if that’s the world I want to be living in, to be real with ya.
Many of us in the music biz, and its many fans too, have been wrestling with how to deal with the ever creeping perversions of AI. Some time ago now, I landed on the conclusion that for the most part, it’s not going to matter to the average everyday listener that doesn’t care how the sausage gets made – if they like what they hear and they want to turn it up, that’s ALL that’s going to matter to them, full stop. And I continue to believe that. Hell, I might even believe that even more now based on this experience. But I’d be lying to you by omission if I didn’t say that this has all made me very sad, and made me even question everything I’m doing, and/or my own ability to even do any of it. All I do is listen – and if I can’t even do that successfully, then who the fuck am I? I feel like I’m supposed to hold myself to a higher standard as a music journalist than that of the average everyday listener – but when the quality of fake music has now risen to the same professional standards of real music, what’s a guy supposed to do? In many ways, I feel totally defeated by this…especially considering the fact that instances like this are only going to get more frequent in the future and even harder to tell. I might have to go back exclusively to buying physical media only if I can’t really trust the online realm as much as I have been able to over the years…and the idea of having to be the sixteen year-old me again paying the management teams and promoters in the machine of BIG MUSIC instead of the incredible people that actually create it, kinda makes me want to severely vomit right where I sit. That money was never meant for them – it was always intended to go to the artists and bands that deserved it, but back then it never did. Hell, if we’re being entirely honest, it STILL doesn’t if you’re in the mainstream…at least not as much as it truly should.
So where does this leave us? Where do we go from here? What are we doing?
I don’t really know any of the answers to those questions, and I’ll fully admit, I’m struggling with it.
Ultimately, I think I’m fine with music of any kind, as long as we’re all honest about how it’s being made. If we’re not doing that, then the deceit is going to be the downfall of the whole situation and what will eventually do me in, permanently. I’m obviously on the side of the true analog creatives…I don’t even like it when people use AI for their artwork, because then things get tagged as AI on social media and shit, and even listeners have to question what YOU create because of how it gets presented. Maybe you put everything you are into everything you do, and maybe you “created” some AI slop quickly for the artwork because it’s cheap and easy to do…but now when that gets posted online, all the public sees is an AI tag that could be for the artwork, could be for the music – who knows, because it doesn’t specify. So be careful if that’s you. In my opinion, you’re way better off just creating some shitty artwork with an old picture out of your personal collection than you are potentially misrepresenting all your hard work with a crappy prompt that gets your shit labeled as AI. Like, I ran into a situation earlier this year with a guy that played over FIFTY some-odd instruments in a single he made, only to have the review I wrote labeled as AI because he used an AI picture for the artwork. FIFTY-plus instruments…which is well beyond the norm, as you know. To the point where most folks wouldn’t even assume that is TRUE to begin with…and then you have a label of AI on it, because of the artwork? That would make anyone question everything, you feel me? So again…be careful about how you go about representing yourself!
I’d never claim to be the sharpest tool in the shed, because believe me, I am definitely not that. I am much more tool than I am anything sharp, I assure you. Even though I do know a few things about music, if something like this can happen to me, there’s a very good chance it can happen to anyone. Good music is always going to be exactly that…as long as you’re listening, we’ve got common ground we can find…I would hope you’re finding ways to support the scene, supporting the creative geniuses that make the music we love, and that you somehow value all that much more than someone that has boiled it all down to “vibe-coding” or whatever, but you do you. Y’all put so much hard work and effort into all that you do, that it’s inspiring to ME on the other side listening, knowing that so many of you have recognized that it’s not about the destination, but the journey itself when it comes to making art & music. For the consumers out there, it’s always going to be about the end product that matters most, and we have a responsibility to recognize that too & understand where they’re coming from – but in turn, it’s my hope of all hopes that they SEE all of what goes into what you do, and they hear it as well.
Don’t stroke out like I did…stay vigilant y’all!
I’ll be back next week with another chapter of The Atrium for those of you that have been following along…we’ll finish off the prologue portions in December here at the site before things get serious and the real story begins in the new year ahead. In between now and then, spread love, be excellent to each other, and turn those tunes you enjoy right the fuck on UP where they belong. Much love and thanks for reading.
Your ally in all-things-music,
– Jer @ SBS